Skip to content

Models of an Atom – SS3 Physics Lesson Note (Second Term)

Lesson note at a glance

Class
SS3
Subject
Physics
Term
Second Term
Reading time
7 min
Start of this note, 4 of 6
Take this term’s notes offline
Reading here is free. Download all 6 SS3 Physics Second term notes as PDF to print and Word to edit.
Download all three terms, ₦2,000
Instant download. Secure payment by Paystack. Card, bank transfer, USSD or OPay. Payment stuck? WhatsApp us.

An atom is a tiny particle that makes up matter, with an estimated diameter of about 10-10 m. A model of the atom is a simple picture or idea that explains its structure and behaviour.

Behavioural objectives

At the end of the lesson, students should be able to:

Advertisement
  1. State and discuss the chemical evidence for the existence of atoms.
  2. Explain the experimental evidence for believing that matter is electrical.
  3. Explain the Bohr-Rutherford model of an atom.
  4. Describe the five main models of the atom in order.
  5. State one success and one limitation of each model.

Instructional resources

  • Chart: a chart showing the diagram of an atom.
  • Chart (optional): a chart comparing the five atomic models.

What is the chemical evidence for atoms?

Chemical evidence for atoms is the set of laws of chemical combination, and the results of electrolysis, that fit best if matter is made of particles.

  • Law of conservation of mass: mass is neither created nor destroyed in a chemical reaction. This fits atoms that only rearrange.
  • Law of definite proportions: a pure compound always contains the same elements in the same mass ratio. Atoms of each element combine in fixed numbers.
  • Law of multiple proportions: when two elements form more than one compound, the masses of one element that combine with a fixed mass of the other are in simple whole-number ratios.
  • Electrolysis: a fixed quantity of electricity always liberates a fixed amount of a substance. This suggests matter is made of particles that carry charge.

What is the experimental evidence that matter is electrical?

Experimental evidence that matter is electrical comes from experiments in which atoms or their parts show electric charge.

  • Charging by friction: rubbing ebonite with fur or glass with silk produces charges. The charges must come from the atoms of the materials.
  • Electrolysis: ions move to the electrodes during electrolysis. This shows that particles of matter carry positive or negative charge.
  • Cathode rays: in a discharge tube, a beam is bent by electric and magnetic fields. The beam is negatively charged.
  • Thomson’s result: the cathode ray particles were the same whatever gas was used. They are electrons, found in all atoms.
  • Neutral atoms: matter is normally uncharged. Each atom has equal positive and negative charge.
Advertisement

What are the particles in an atom?

An atom contains three main particles: protons, neutrons and electrons.

Particle Charge Position
Proton Positive Nucleus
Neutron None Nucleus
Electron Negative Outside the nucleus, about 1/1840 of the mass of a proton
  • Neutral atom: the number of protons equals the number of electrons.

What are the models of the atom?

There are five main models of the atom: Dalton’s, Thomson’s, Rutherford’s, Bohr’s and the electron cloud model.

  • Atom: so small that it cannot be seen with an ordinary microscope.
  • Models: scientists use experiments, mathematics and models to understand atoms.
  • Improvement: each new model corrected faults in the earlier one.

The main models, in order, are:

  1. Dalton’s atomic model
  2. The plum pudding model, proposed by J. J. Thomson
  3. The planetary or nuclear model, proposed by Ernest Rutherford
  4. Bohr’s atomic model
  5. The electron cloud atomic model

What is Dalton’s atomic model?

Dalton’s model, from 1803, pictures the atom as a solid, indivisible sphere.

  • Year: 1803, the first model of the atom.
  • Main idea: atoms are indivisible and are the building blocks of matter.
  • Same element: all atoms of one element are alike.
  • Different elements: their atoms differ in mass and properties.
  • Compounds: atoms combine in simple whole-number ratios.
  • Reactions: atoms are rearranged, and are not created or destroyed.
  • Success: it explained the laws of chemical combination.
  • Limitation: atoms can be divided into smaller particles.

Dalton's model showing the atom as a solid indivisible sphere

What is Thomson’s model?

Thomson’s model, also called the plum pudding model, pictures the atom as a positive sphere with electrons embedded in it.

  • Year: 1904, known as the plum pudding model.
  • Main idea: the atom is a sphere of positive charge with electrons embedded in it.
  • Comparison: the electrons are like plums or raisins in a pudding.
  • Success: it showed that atoms contain electrons and are electrically neutral.
  • Limitation: it could not explain Rutherford’s scattering results.
Advertisement

Thomson's plum pudding model with electrons embedded in a positive sphere

What is Rutherford’s model?

Rutherford’s model, also called the nuclear or planetary model, pictures the atom as a small, dense, positive nucleus with electrons orbiting it.

  • Year: 1911, known as the nuclear or planetary model.
  • Main idea: the atom is mostly empty space with a small, dense nucleus at the centre.
  • Nucleus: it carries positive charge and holds nearly all the mass. It is now known to contain protons and neutrons.
  • Electrons: they orbit the nucleus like planets round the Sun.
  • Success: it explained the results of the alpha scattering experiment.
  • Limitation: it could not explain why orbiting electrons do not lose energy and fall into the nucleus.

Rutherford's nuclear model with electrons orbiting a central nucleus

What was Rutherford’s alpha scattering experiment?

Rutherford’s alpha scattering experiment fired alpha particles at thin gold foil to find out how the positive charge is arranged in an atom.

  1. A beam of alpha particles was fired at a very thin gold foil.
  2. A screen around the foil showed where the particles landed.
  3. Most particles passed straight through. Conclusion: the atom is mostly empty space.
  4. A few particles were deflected through large angles. Conclusion: the centre is positively charged.
  5. Very few particles bounced almost straight back. Conclusion: the nucleus is small, dense and heavy.

What is Bohr’s model (the Bohr-Rutherford model)?

Bohr’s model pictures electrons moving in fixed orbits, or shells, round a small positive nucleus, each orbit having a definite energy.

  • Year: 1913, Niels Bohr improved Rutherford’s model.
  • Nucleus: the atom has a small, positive nucleus at the centre.
  • Energy levels: electrons move only in fixed orbits (shells), each with a definite energy.
  • Stable orbits: an electron in an allowed orbit does not radiate energy.
  • Jumping: an electron moves to a higher level by absorbing energy.
  • Falling: an electron falling to a lower level emits a photon of energy E = hf, where h is Planck’s constant and f is the frequency.
  • Success: it explained the line spectrum of hydrogen.
  • Limitation: it does not work well for atoms with many electrons.
Advertisement
n = 1 n = 2 n = 3 Green: nucleus. Dark dots: electrons.
Electron shells in the Bohr model. Schematic only: the electron numbers do not belong to a real atom. Based on standard physics texts.

What is the electron cloud model?

The electron cloud model pictures electrons as spread in regions of probability round the nucleus, with no fixed paths.

  • Origin: developed in the 1920s from quantum mechanics.
  • Main idea: electrons do not follow fixed paths round the nucleus.
  • Electron cloud: it is a region where an electron is most likely to be found.
  • Orbital: the name for such a region of space.
  • Density: a denser cloud means a higher chance of finding the electron.
  • Success: it explains the behaviour of atoms with many electrons, which Bohr’s model could not.
  • Limitation: it is hard to picture and needs advanced mathematics.
  • Status: it is the model accepted today.

How do the models compare?

The table below puts the five models side by side, from the earliest to the latest.

Model Scientist Year Key idea
Solid sphere Dalton 1803 Atoms are indivisible
Plum pudding J. J. Thomson 1904 Electrons embedded in positive sphere
Nuclear Rutherford 1911 Small dense nucleus, mostly empty space
Energy level Bohr 1913 Electrons in fixed shells
Electron cloud Quantum mechanics 1920s Electrons found in probability regions

What are the applications of atomic models?

Atomic models are used to explain how atoms behave and interact.

  1. Line spectra: each element emits light of its own wavelengths.
  2. Atomic structure: the models guide the study of the atom and the nucleus.
  3. Chemical bonding: the arrangement of electrons explains how atoms join.

Evaluation

  1. Explain J. J. Thomson’s atomic model.
  2. What was the success of Thomson’s atomic model?
  3. State two conclusions from Rutherford’s alpha scattering experiment.
  4. How does the Bohr model explain the emission of light by an atom?
  5. Name one piece of chemical evidence for atoms.

Assignment

  • Task: draw and label the Dalton, Thomson and Rutherford models, and state one limitation of each.

Reference material

  1. New System Physics for Secondary Schools by Dr. Charles Chew et al.
  2. New School Physics by M. W. Anyakoha
  3. Internet facility

This term's Physics topics

SS3 Second Term · 6 topics

  1. Electromagnetic Field
  2. Electromagnetic Induction
  3. Simple AC Circuit
  4. Models of an Atom
  5. Nucleus & Radioactivity, Nuclear Reaction.
  6. Energy Quantization
Advertisement

Lesson Notes for Other Classes

Print it or edit it in Word

Every note is free to read online. A PDF or Word copy of one subject costs ₦1,000 for one term, or ₦2,000 for all three terms.

Sign in first, then choose your class and subject at checkout.