Binary Operations Properties – SS3 Mathematics Lesson Note (First Term)
Lesson note at a glance
- Class
- SS3
- Subject
- Mathematics
- Term
- First Term
- Reading time
- 6 min
A binary operation is a rule that combines any two elements of a non-empty set to give a single element.
- Symbols: binary operations are usually written with symbols such as * and ⊕.
- Result: the answer may or may not belong to the set under consideration.
- Everyday examples: addition, subtraction and multiplication of numbers are binary operations.
Behavioural objectives
By the end of the lesson, students should be able to:
- define a binary operation;
- test whether a set is closed under a binary operation;
- show whether a binary operation is commutative;
- show whether a binary operation is associative;
- show whether one binary operation distributes over another;
- find the identity element of a binary operation.
What are the properties of a binary operation?
There are four main properties of a binary operation: closure, commutativity, associativity and distributivity.
- Closure: combining two elements of the set always gives an element of the set.
- Commutative: the order of the two elements does not change the result.
- Associative: the way three elements are grouped does not change the result.
- Distributive: one operation can be spread over another operation.
| Property | Condition to test | Number of elements |
|---|---|---|
| Closure | a * b ∈ S | 2 |
| Commutative | a * b = b * a | 2 |
| Associative | (a * b) * c = a * (b * c) | 3 |
| Distributive | a * (b ∘ c) = (a * b) ∘ (a * c) | 3 |
What is the closure property?
A non-empty set Z is closed under a binary operation * if a * b ∈ Z for all a, b ∈ Z.
Steps to test closure:
- Pick elements from the set.
- Apply the rule to them.
- Check that each answer is in the set.
- One answer outside the set is enough to show the set is not closed.
Example: A binary operation * is defined on the set S = {0, 1, 2, 3, 4} by x * y = x + y – xy. Find:
- 2 * 4
- 3 * 1
- 0 * 3
Is the set S closed under the operation *?
Solution
- 2 * 4, that is x = 2, y = 4: 2 + 4 – (2 × 4) = 6 – 8 = -2
- 3 * 1 = 3 + 1 – (3 × 1) = 4 – 3 = 1
- 0 * 3 = 0 + 3 – (0 × 3) = 3
Since -2 ∉ S, the operation * is not closed in S.
What is the commutative property?
If S is a non-empty set closed under the binary operation *, then * is commutative if a * b = b * a for all a, b ∈ S.
- Meaning: the order of combination does not affect the result.
- Commutative: addition and multiplication of real numbers, since 3 + 2 = 2 + 3.
- Not commutative: subtraction, since 3 – 2 ≠ 2 – 3.
Steps to test commutativity:
- Write a * b using the rule.
- Write b * a by swapping the two letters in the rule.
- Compare the two results.
- If they are equal for all values, the operation is commutative.
Example: The operation * on the set R of real numbers is defined by p * q = p³ + q³ – 3pq. Is the operation commutative?
Solution
- p * q = p³ + q³ – 3pq
- Commutative condition: p * q = q * p
- To get q * p, use the same rule but replace p by q and q by p.
- q * p = q³ + p³ – 3qp
- Since q³ + p³ – 3qp = p³ + q³ – 3pq, we have p * q = q * p.
The operation is commutative.
What is the associative property?
If a non-empty set S is closed under a binary operation *, then * is associative if (a * b) * c = a * (b * c) for all a, b, c ∈ S.
- Meaning: the grouping of three elements does not affect the result.
- Associative: addition of real numbers, since (1 + 2) + 3 = 1 + (2 + 3).
- Not associative: division, since (8 ÷ 4) ÷ 2 = 1 but 8 ÷ (4 ÷ 2) = 4.
Steps to test associativity:
- Introduce a third element c.
- Work out the left side, (a * b) * c, by doing the bracket first.
- Work out the right side, a * (b * c), by doing the bracket first.
- Compare both sides.
Example: The operation ⊕ on the set Z of integers is defined by a ⊕ b = 2a + 3b – 1. Determine whether or not the operation is associative in Z.
Solution
Associative condition: (a ⊕ b) ⊕ c = a ⊕ (b ⊕ c)
Left side:
- (a ⊕ b) ⊕ c = (2a + 3b – 1) ⊕ c
- = 2(2a + 3b – 1) + 3c – 1
- = 4a + 6b – 2 + 3c – 1
- = 4a + 6b + 3c – 3
Right side:
- a ⊕ (b ⊕ c) = a ⊕ (2b + 3c – 1)
- = 2a + 3(2b + 3c – 1) – 1
- = 2a + 6b + 9c – 3 – 1
- = 2a + 6b + 9c – 4
Since (a ⊕ b) ⊕ c ≠ a ⊕ (b ⊕ c), the operation is not associative in Z.
What is the distributive property?
If a set S is closed under two binary operations * and ∘, then * is distributive over ∘ if, for all a, b, c ∈ S, both of these hold:
- Left distributive: a * (b ∘ c) = (a * b) ∘ (a * c).
- Right distributive: (b ∘ c) * a = (b * a) ∘ (c * a).
- Familiar example: multiplication distributes over addition, since 2 × (3 + 4) = (2 × 3) + (2 × 4).
- Order matters: * may distribute over ∘ without ∘ distributing over *.
Example: Given the set R of real numbers under the operations * and ∘ defined by a * b = a + b – 3 and a ∘ b = 5ab for all a, b ∈ R, does * distribute over ∘?
Solution
- Let a, b, c ∈ R. The condition is a * (b ∘ c) = (a * b) ∘ (a * c).
- Left side: a * (b ∘ c) = a * (5bc) = a + 5bc – 3
- Right side: (a * b) ∘ (a * c) = (a + b – 3) ∘ (a + c – 3) = 5(a + b – 3)(a + c – 3)
- Expanding the right side gives terms such as 5a² that do not appear on the left side.
- Check with a = b = c = 1: left side = 1 + 5 – 3 = 3, right side = 5(-1)(-1) = 5.
Since 3 ≠ 5, a * (b ∘ c) ≠ (a * b) ∘ (a * c). Therefore * does not distribute over ∘.
What are the identity and inverse of a binary operation?
The identity element e of a binary operation * is the element for which a * e = e * a = a for every a in the set.
- Identity of addition: 0, since a + 0 = a.
- Identity of multiplication: 1, since a × 1 = a.
- Inverse: the inverse of a is the element that combines with a to give the identity e.
Example: Find the identity element of x * y = x + y – xy on the set of real numbers.
Solution
- Let e be the identity. Then x * e = x.
- x + e – xe = x
- e – xe = 0
- e(1 – x) = 0
- This holds for every x only when e = 0.
The identity element is 0.
Evaluation
- An operation * on the set R of real numbers is defined by x * y = 3x + 2y – 1. Find (a) 2 * 3 (b) -4 * 5 (c) 1 * 1 (d) 1/3 * 1/2. Is the operation closed?
- A binary operation * is defined on the set R of real numbers by x * y = x + y + 3xy. Determine whether or not * is (a) commutative, (b) associative.
- The operation ⊕ on the set R of real numbers is defined by a ⊕ b = (a + b)/2 + ab. Show that ⊕ is commutative but not associative on R.
- The operations * and ⊕ are defined on the set N of natural numbers by a * b = ab and a ⊕ b = a/b. (a) Does * distribute over ⊕? (b) Does ⊕ distribute over *?
- Find the identity element of the operation x * y = x + y + 3xy on R.
Assignment
Answer all parts, then complete the reading.
- Two binary operations * and ⊕ are defined as m * n = mn – n – 1 and m ⊕ n = mn + n – 2 for all real numbers m and n. Find the value of 3 ⊕ (4 * 5). (a) 60 (b) 57 (c) 54 (d) 42
- The binary operation * is defined on the set of integers p and q by p * q = pq + p + q. Find 2 * (3 * 4). (a) 59 (b) 19 (c) 67 (d) 38
- A binary operation ⊕ on real numbers is defined by x ⊕ y = xy + x + y for any two real numbers x and y. The value of (-3/4) ⊕ 6 is: (a) 3/4 (b) -9/2 (c) 45/4 (d) -3/4
- The operation * is defined on the set R of real numbers by a * b = (a + b)/2 – 1 for all a, b ∈ R. Is the operation * commutative in R?
- Reading: Binary Operation, Further Mathematics Project II, pages 13 to 22.
This term's Mathematics topics
SS3 First Term · 9 topics
- Logic
- Application of Surds to Trigonometry Ratio and Trigonometry Graph
- Matrices and Determinant
- Calculating Distances Using Longitude, Latitude & Great Circles
- Surface Area and Volume of Sphere and Hemispherical Sphere Volume
- Longitude and Latitude
- Binary Operations Properties
- Arithmetic of Finance
- Simple Equations and Variations

